The Lilywhite Ledger logo

THE LILYWHITE LEDGER

Tottenham Hotspur News, Analysis & Features

Independent football journalism from Will Witts

Tottenham lodge official complaint to Pro Ref with pundits and ex-referees split

Will Witts•09/11/2026
Tottenham lodge official complaint to Pro Ref with pundits and ex-referees split

Spurs want answers after Mathys Tel was forced off by a challenge that drew only a foul despite a lengthy VAR check, with ex-referees and pundits divided on whether it deserved a red card.

Tottenham will make a formal complaint to Pro Ref over the decision not to send off Leeds defender Jayden Bogle for his challenge on Mathys Tel in Saturday’s 1-0 defeat away at Elland Road.

Bogle caught Tel with his studs on his Achilles. Referee John Brooks awarded a foul but showed no card, and Tel was unable to continue and was substituted before half-time. A four-minute VAR review followed, but Tony Harrington did not recommend an on-field review, deeming the challenge only “reckless”. Harrington said there was a lack of speed going into the challenge and that Bogle was stepping into the tackle.

The Press Association understands Spurs will write to Pro Ref to seek clarification on why Bogle was not shown a red card. The club may also cite the red card shown to Crystal Palace’s Jean-Philippe Mateta for his foul on Micky van de Ven a week earlier. Mateta is serving a three-match suspension after the FA rejected Palace’s appeal.

Spurs boss Roberto De Zerbi was measured after the match. He said he had “big confidence in the referee” and that he could not say whether it was a red card. He was more pointed about consistency, however. He said he was certain Pedro Porro’s second-half yellow card for a challenge on Nmecha was justified, and that the referee’s “parameter” was “not good enough” for both situations. De Zerbi has described Tel’s problem as a “bad injury”.

On Sky Sports’ Ref Watch, former Premier League referee Dermot Gallagher said: “I think it is a red card; he is extremely lucky.” He pointed to the directive covering challenges above the ankle or on the Achilles, and compared the incident with Ryan Sessegnon’s red card for Fulham and Mateta’s dismissal.

Panellist Jay Bothroyd was more sympathetic to Bogle but reached the same conclusion on the law. He said he does not want to see red cards for such challenges. He added that, going by the consistency of the law, it has to be given.

Mike Dean, reacting live on Soccer Saturday, called it “100 per cent a red”. Former assistant referee Darren Cann told BBC Sport the challenge met the criteria for serious foul play. Former Spurs boss Tim Sherwood said he would not have been surprised by a red.

Others disagreed. Glenn Hoddle told TNT Sports that in real time he thought it was “probably a yellow”, adding that the game isn’t played in slow motion.

On talkSPORT, Martin Keown said the challenge “looks reckless”. Simon Jordan also backed Spurs’ decision to complain, arguing that if a club believes a decision is wrong, it should make a stand and hold officials to account.

The Key Match Incidents Panel will review the decision in the coming days, while Tottenham await an explanation from Pro Ref. The complaint cannot change the result or hand Spurs a retrospective red card. Because the incident was reviewed by VAR, further action against Bogle is unlikely.

The benefits are indirect. A written explanation puts the officials’ reasoning on the record, and a ruling that the challenge should have been a red would strengthen the club’s case on consistency after Mateta’s dismissal. It would also give Spurs leverage in any future disputed incident.

Leeds have said they are “appalled” by racist abuse aimed at Bogle on social media after the incident. They have said they will work with the Premier League and authorities to identify those responsible.

WW

Will Witts

Contributor to The Lilywhite Ledger

Related Articles